Reunion

Review contains some spoilers.  A spoiler warning is given beforehand.

Reunion is a 2D survival horror game developed during a four-day game jam known as GameZanga (a Pan-Arabian jam hosted by Arabian game site GameTako). The team members included Maan Ashgar (Artist), Ahmed Al-Haddad (Designer), and Abdullah Konash (Game Design/Programming).

They describe their game as a “short, shocking horror game”, with a warning in the intro screen that “The game contains violent scenes and scary sounds” and that the player is encouraged that the “Usage of headphones is recommended”.

intro-text

Now that the cold hard facts are out of the way, let’s get this review going.

Reunion does one thing extremely well, and that’s sound design. At first I thought it was going to wow me with its aesthetics as well, since you are first treated to a beautifully illustrated title screen with what appears to be a small child holding a stuffed animal, lost in a purple hued wooded area. Unfortunately the aesthetics take a nose dive as the first cut scene (a child running from their home into the woods) has the look of a rough storyboard and has absolutely no animation. Once you are dumped into the game you see that the game has very basic aesthetics, almost cartoon and childlike, that you might expect from a quickly put together game created during a jam.

aesthetics-chart

Mind you, that’s not to say the actual in-game aesthetics are bad. They have a very beautiful charm to them. The character you control is a slightly disheveled man, the father of the child from the intro. The art style is very distinctive, with the father’s head being over sized, which allows the player a chance to see what seems to be a very worried look in his eyes, and the colors and lines are very soft… so there’s an almost pleasant, water-color like atmosphere to the visuals.

The father is surrounded by darkness and as you begin to move him around you see trees and rocks that are created in the same soft water-color style. My first impression was that the aesthetics looked too pleasant for this game to live up to its claim of being a shocking horror game, but people on Game Jolt (the indie site the game is hosted on) seemed to be raving about it, so I decided to persevere.

bandicam 2013-10-06 18-06-39-658

It wasn’t the hype that drew me, but rather the wonderful sound design. From the very beginning you are treated to one of the more impressive soundtracks I have heard in quite some time in an indie game (or in some AAA games for that matter). Not only was the music wonderful, but it was nice to hear actual voices as the father and child, both of which have speaking parts in the game with the father being able to call out to his child, as well as the child’s breath and footsteps being heard as he appears to run deeper and deeper into the forest.

It’s very interesting how the simple combination of hearing a real person’s voice alongside a moving soundtrack can help enhance the aesthetics (and gameplay, which I will get into in a second) of a game that I think otherwise would not be very engaging.

As you begin to move the father around, searching the woods for his child (whose direction is indicated not only by sounds, but also an arrow that appears every time you have the father call out his name), one of the first sounds you will hear is that of a hissing snake. The closer you get to the snake the more intense and menacing the sound, until finally you will most likely stumble upon the source of the noise, which no surprise, is a snake.

bandicam 2013-10-06 18-10-33-295

This is where the game mechanics are revealed, as once you are too close to the snake, a jarring noise rings out, the camera centers on the snake, and you are returned to a predetermined start position to try again. Pretty simple, right? Go through the forest, using your ears and the ability to call out to the father’s child to reveal the directional arrow… avoid creatures in the woods and presumably save the father’s son.

Once again, the best thing about this game is the sound design, but in my humble opinion, everything else falls short. While the jarring sound that is associated with seeing that first snake and the sounds of a slithering creature along with the moody soundtrack is definitely something that may get you a little spooked, the stylized cartoonish graphics are enough to take me out of the immersion. The snake is as stylized as anything else, but is equally as static as the rocks and trees. As you move the father deeper into the woods you will also come across bears which are equally cartoonish and project equally spooky sounds.

When you begin to get in the rhythm of “listen for sound, avoid sounds, follow directional arrow”, the game quickly loses its charm and the immersion is utterly broken. Not only that, but while the game developers attempt to do a decent job of creating directional sound in the game, they opt for the growls and hisses and the child running through the woods to be more expressionistic and ambient, sometimes confusingly panning around the stereo field in a way that is hard to get a fix on where to move the father. On the other hand, the confusing nature of the sound design and the inability to see much around you in the game (they obscure much of the screen with a ring of blackness, typical of creating “darkness” in a 2D game) does a fantastic job of obfuscating the very simple nature of the level design.

Though the level design is technically very simple, and it’s nice to feel like the forest is larger and more complex than it actually is, the fact that it’s hard to get your bearings every time you are reset can lead to the game sometimes feeling more frustrating rather than immersive. Thankfully as you get deeper into the forest, the game warps you to trees that have numbered “DANGER” signs so that you begin to realize you are making progress.

bandicam 2013-10-06 18-07-04-629

[ WARNING : Spoilers below! ]

An interesting thing happened to me while playing the game. About half way through (mind you it is very short, probably 10 minutes at the most if you are doing well), and I once again credit this to the wonderful sound design, I actually became somewhat immersed in spite of how silly the cartoonish snakes, bears, trees, and rocks were.

Somewhere between the somber music, the sounds of the child running through the forest, the father calling out in desperation for his child, and the anxiety of having to avoid the dangerous forest creatures…. somewhere between all of that, I actually began to get into the mindset of what it would be like to be a parent running after their kid who is lost in a dangerous place.

It was right about that time that the game kicked the tension up a notch. Instead of the familiar sounds of animals, I began to hear more alien noises. Psychedelic warbles and shifting that reminds me of heavy experiences I’ve had on LSD. The kinds of sounds I always associate with really good sound design in horror games and moody psychedelic rock.

But the alien noises aren’t just arbitrary, they pulse and flow as you get closer to a new enemy, an eery silhouetted figure of the father with empty glowing eyes.

bandicam 2013-10-06 18-06-50-757

I’ll admit, the first time I saw one of the silhouetted figures and the camera jumped, and the jarring noise of being seen played I got a bit freaked out.

This was the one moment where I feel like they did well with the aesthetics of the game, as the contrast between the cartoonish looking father and the eery dark silhouette really drew me in. I want to stress that I’m not saying the art style is bad, and I truly believe the illustrator did a great job of creating a wonderful look of concern on the father’s face… but if it weren’t for the incredibly engaging sounds I don’t think I would have been as shocked or immersed by the middle point of the game.

Something about the weary looking eyes of the father in contrast to the dead glowing eyes of the silhouetted doppelgänger along with the unnerving noises truly made the middle section of the game worthy of a horror title.

iveseensomeshit

Now let’s talk about the ending.

It’s hard for me to talk about the ending.

I’ll just tell you what happens and we’ll go from there. After a short but challenging period of having to avoid the silhouetted doppelgängers, you finally come to what appears to be a bunker or mine shaft that leads underground.

I’m sure you can imagine what may or may not happen next. I mean, the game promised violent scenes after all, and while there have been some “shocking” moments, nothing violent has happened.

scary

Once you approach the underground entrance, the game takes control away from you and dumps you once again into a very low quality storyboard style, non-animated, cut scene where you see the child with their stuffed animal and as the camera pans to the right, you see a gun. Then it cuts inexplicably to the more cartoonish style once again, of the father pointing a gun directly at the screen, as though you are looking from the perspective of the child. The screen goes black, a gun shot is heard.

twist

A twist worthy of the master himself.

Here’s the thing. I’m okay with a game like this. A game where you play as a deranged lunatic who is so off their rocker that they would chase their child down into a forest and then mercilessly murder them. I think we need more games like this. More people should be unafraid to tackle tough subjects involving the nature of violence in humanity as well as other challenging subjects most people are afraid to confront through the interactive medium of video games.

gta v main

But, the game didn’t end there. The very next thing you see after the gun shot and fade to black, is the following statement.

“Mental illness is a fact, and those who are ill think, but they think in an unpredictable way.”

Well fuck you very much, but as someone who struggles with mental illness (I’d argue we all do), this statement is absolutely the most ridiculous thing I have ever read in a video game, and I play a lot of thoughtlessly made, culturally subversive piece of shit video games.

It then follows that up quickly with…

“Click on the Wiki button for more information on (Schizophrenia).”

bandicam 2013-10-06 18-09-17-407

imageOooooohhhh, well in that case, yeah, that’s totally cool, because people who deal with Schizophrenia are all violent psychopaths who can’t be trusted and will more than likely bring harm to their loved ones. I’m glad that this game is getting the word out there that people need to remain diligent and afraid of people dealing with mental illness, especially extreme mental illness such as Schizophrenia.

Paint the walls with my brain and don’t tell anyone I was the head of MKULTRA because fuck all of that noise.

Seriously. I’m the first to defend a game for having flawed depictions of women, men, queers, cultures, babies, robots, whatever in the name of artistic freedom, but making factually incorrect statements, and literally preceding them with “FACT”, specifically in a game that creates a correlation of irrational violence and something as broad as mental illness and Schizophrenia (fun FACT : Schizophrenia is a spectrum of mental illness which they would have known if they followed their own wiki link)…. is either incredibly ignorant… incredibly manipulative (see : Oscar bait)… or just plain malicious.

enlighten

I’m more disappointed in the droves of people who bought into it than I am of the creators themselves. I can deal with some ignorance on their part, but the hype that was built up around this game (it has tens of thousands of plays with many people expressing at how moved they were by the experience)… it just makes me a little depressed (FACT : depression is a mental illness that many people suffer from and don’t get treatment for because of FACT: the stigma of mental illness).

bandicam 2013-10-06 18-12-00-944Reunion was developed by Maan Ashgar (Artist), Ahmed Al-Haddad (Designer), and Abdullah Konash (Game Design/Programming).

FACT : This game is free to play on Game Jolt.

Advertisements

6 Responses to Reunion

  1. shinhogosha says:

    That’s…unfortunate about the message after the ending. I almost don’t want to comment on the review because, with how absurdly offensive and ignorant that message is, I’d rather not even give the game a second thought or any publicity at all by talking about it. But, since I’m here…

    …fuck that shit. Fuck it with a rake.

    FACT: Any rake will do.

  2. Mike says:

    I must be missing something. I read that wiki article and I can’t find anything in there about schizophrenics being child killing pyschopaths.

    I’m sure the developers researched this topic thoroughly and that their understanding of schizophrenia is not limited to the cliche about split personalities. Which, fact, is not a fact.

  3. Gritfish says:

    I tried to write a response earlier, but it’s impossible to separate the things I liked about this game from the things I can’t stand:
    (in the style of the Simpson’s frogurt scene: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_pqnsKWlpc)

    The sound design / calling for your son mechanic really sets a tense atmosphere (that’s good), but the resulting arrow often leads you straight into instant failure (that’s bad).
    The failures restart you at increasingly numbered “warning signs” which is a clever metaphor as you ignore them and keep going (that’s good), but it leads you to think maybe that running into the dopplegangers is how you progress (that’s bad).
    I had an actual moment of relief when I reached the mine (that’s good, even though I knew the ending ahead of time), but the twist isn’t given much time to sink in, and the “explanatory” text afterwards is a ham-fisted slap in the face (FACT: that’s bad).

    While there ARE some aspects of the game that I did like, they’re completely undone by that one sentence in the end screen. Had you seen a glimpse of the gun as you were walking, or seen some hint of “why” the son ran, it may have felt less like they slapped the story on to what was an otherwise interesting system.

  4. BigDaddyBushyJ says:

    The way you’ve interpreted the message seems to be what has caused you offence. I’ve read the ,message in the screenshot a few times, and I would have automatically assumed that it’s trying to make “normal” people understand that the way someone with a certain mental illness may think is differently from others. It’s not saying people with mental illness are all deranged, or patronisingly pointing out that it is what’s responsible for the actions of *some* people who do terrible things and happen to be ill. Seems more of an attempt to be understanding, than patronising or ignorant.

    I’d also observe that you’ve been offended by it because it’s an issue that affects *you* directly. If that’s how you want to react to people who make observations about this sort of thing, fine, but you sound no less ignorant than the developer here that you bemoan.

    • shinhogosha says:

      Except for the fact that the game is about a guy who hunts down and kills his own son. Like, out of context, the final screen/message COULD be taken the way you say. But after you just played a character who, after putting a bullet through a child’s head, gets labeled as schizophrenic, it’s impossible to take it that way.

      In other words, schizophrenia is being tied to murder in the same way a bigot would broadly tie homosexuality to HIV. It’s REALLY offensive, and will remain so even if the developer didn’t intend it to be.

      Also, I’m not schizophrenic. I have no close ties to anyone affected with it. I have no claim in this. I’m just stating what’s right there because, holy crap, it’s offensive.

  5. An XBLIG Guy says:

    This topic is really difficult. Do any of you know if any of the developer’s team have dealt with mental illness? Videogame development can be seen as a form or art, and sometimes we use it to express ourselves. My fear is that this game was not meant to make a statement, but it was supposed to be an outlet, for art’s sake.

    I’m not taking sides, of course. Sometimes art is offensive.

What do you think?

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: